N.B. I’m a little annoyed, and this comes from some long-standing annoyance I haven’t been able to explain until now, so bear with me.
Feel free to put this in your TL;DR pile if you’re so inclined.
About fifteen years ago, I lived with a wonderful family as an au pair in the Netherlands. They were a family very unlike my own, which, especially at the time, was a very good thing to see, and they will always be some of my favorite people in the whole world. They gave me a different view of life and the world to ponder, and it changed me profoundly.
These days, I have a family of my own, and I sometimes despair at the propensity of other people to try to take the shape of it, to judge and ponder and try to evaluate this part of my life that means more to me than anything. In Germany, this is a particular issue; many people feel entitled to have an opinion on everything and more entitled to express that opinion, even when it is not only none of their business, but also something they have no hope of understanding.
And suddenly, I find myself returning to a comment the father in my host family (hi Peter!
) once made to me when I was speculating on my parents’ marriage, one which I didn’t take very seriously at the time, but which has turned out to be one of the most honest and true things I’ve ever had to digest. I find myself reminded of it again and again, and now that I’m married myself, I am struck both by the truth of it and how much I did not understand this before I was married myself. It was probably an offhand comment, one I doubt he’d remember having made, and I’m sure I’ve got the wording of what he said wrong, but this is what he said:
Marriages are strange things. You never understand a marriage unless you’re in it.
Substitute whatever synonym for “committed relationship you can’t just walk away from” you like in there — I’m not one of those people that believes a particular idea of marriage is right and good and true — but it turns out to be very true. And it turns out to be very hard to believe if you’ve never been married.
Don’t ask me why; that’s just how it is.
I married a very obviously unique person, and, in the end, after what was (for better or worse) a lot of experience, I prefer truth in advertising. One of the downsides of being such a person (I’m this way too to a large extent) is that it leaves you open to all sorts of speculation and commentary, but I think the benefits outweigh the drawbacks.
My husband is brilliant and honest and warm and loving and opinionated and complicated and dedicated and always, always surprising. He is not perfect, but no one is. He is also someone I love to distraction – he puts up with my quirks, and I put up with his, and there is wonderful stuff that makes those quirks largely not matter (and sometimes even endearing).
I’m usually very straightforward about how our relationship started, because, almost 13 years later, I find it funny, in retrospect.
I didn’t really like him at first – he teased too much, and I found him intimidating, and, like most people, I vastly underestimated him.
In the end, we became close friends and after about six months of working myself up to it, I asked him out. He sort-of-but-not-really turned me down, going off to Germany and coming back a month later telling me he’d thought it over and that the answer was “yes”, surprising the living shit out of me. And more than a decade later, through all of the ups and downs, we’re still together, we have a wonderful child, and with have this marriage thing, which I never expected but treasure greatly.
I never wanted to get married, really, but it’s what happened. We have this marriage, this beautiful and strange and difficult thing. It is what it is.
This marriage, which sometimes people who have no business speculating about do anyway.
Cut it out – you’re not going to understand it.
I’ve been informed by people who thought they knew better that — and if you know me, this is going to make you choke — “I’m pretty sure there’d be no Mrs. Grothoff if you hadn’t asked him out”, in the midst of speculation about whether or not he’d openly ogle women (with the open implication that if he did not, he was abnormal). As if being a wife was ever my goal (and call me “Mrs.” at your own risk – I bite), as if my husband wouldn’t and couldn’t make such a decision on his own.
You never understand a marriage unless you’re in it.
And just now, open wonder about the fact that Christian is headed off to Costa Rica on vacation by himself.
You never understand a marriage unless you’re in it.
One thing Americans never expect about Germany is that is bloody patriarchal and there does seem to be this idea that men do certain things, and men that don’t do them are abnormal (and men that do have to be tolerated no matter what). That women do things (largely things involving being bossy and controlling and not accepting that men and women are different), and that this is the way of things. I’m not saying every German thinks this way; I think it’s strong stereotyping though, and people play to stereotypes.
Personally, I think this comes from the fact that German feminism is, in large part, both terrifying and, frankly, IMHO a form of bullying, but regardless, as much as I have no problem with the fact that men and women have some physical differences, we’re all fucking grownups here.
Me asking a not-obviously-shy man out is not abnormal, and indicates neither that I am a forward woman who likes to take control of things nor that there’s anything wrong with the man and that he’s not interested.
You never understand a marriage unless you’re in it.
My husband’s propensity to appreciate women while trying to be gentlemanly/not crass about it (and it is, exactly, that, but it’s really none of your business and I don’t feel the need to go into detail) does not make him somehow abnormal. If you want the truth, ogling some girl and then apologizing to the women around you (who probably couldn’t care less) is a lot more bizarre IMHO. Cultural, perhaps, but not for someone else to judge in either case.
The fact that we don’t celebrate Valentine’s Day doesn’t make us unromantic. We have other things.
The fact that we take vacations together and sometimes alone doesn’t make our marriage odd – we just realized early on that we were two individuals, and even if we’re married and we form a family unit, if you let those individuals die, your marriage can go with it.
The fact that I understand why people get frustrated with my husband sometimes – the fact that I express such frustration myself sometimes – doesn’t mean I want to participate in anyone else’s issues with him. And I’m sure the reverse applies – I am a frustrating person often enough.
He doesn’t wear his wedding ring. So what? I like it when he does, but it’s never been a requirement.
I don’t wear mine because it’s broken at the moment, but I do tend to wear it. So what? It’s never been a requirement.
Whatever that means to us exists within the bounds of a marriage and you are not going to understand it.
My husband spends lots and lots of time with his son, often picks him up from school, and does housework. I hate housework, work full-time, and also spend lots and lots of time with our son. Sometimes we do it together, sometimes we do it apart. It’s our marriage, our family, and you are not going to understand it.
There are things that happen to you in a relationship as a result of nursing each other through personal loss other people will never be allowed to see, the birth or arrival of a child, the experience of the darkest darkness (and lightest light) of another person’s soul that they can’t hide, long-shared jokes and thrills and wounds, time and time and time, and those things become even more cryptic to the outside world as the decades pass.
Let me tell you something else: you don’t understand your parents’ marriage either, even if you’ve been stuck in the middle of it your whole life.
You’ll have to trust me on this one. I learned it the hard way.
There are some things in life that you’ll never fully grasp until and unless you’ve done them. It doesn’t make you a lesser person, but it does mean you don’t have access to understanding them. Marriage and parenting are two of those that blindside everyone because we’re able to observe them all the time, but I promise you, no matter how smart or observant you are, they are not going to be what you think. Sometimes that’s good, sometimes it’s hard, but regardless, it just is.
Marriages are strange things. You never understand a marriage unless you’re in it.
So please refrain from speculation and wonder about mine. I’m in it, and it’s the one I want. Anything else is just blind speculation.